I am currently reading the entire archives of Prepare to Meet Your Bakerina, the blog of one Jen McAllister, a baker who revels in all things foodie. She also has a fun, arch writing style, describing herself as “the Biggest Baking Nerd in the World” and working on a history of the egg in baking for a fellowship in Arkansas. (I haven’t gotten to the entries about how the fellowship went, yet.)
I have mentioned before that I am not a fan of faux populism, the idea that haute is automatically inferior to bistro, which is automatically inferior to home. (Granted, I *do* tend to favor home-cooked food, particularly the kind known in France as “cuisine de mere;” it is what I’d prefer to eat and certainly what I’d prefer to cook, but I believe that you can love your grandma’s beef stew without spitting all over the daube at your local four-star.) But if I don’t like faux populism, I absolutely, positively hate faux gourmandism, the idea that a high price tag justifies splashing about expensive ingredients hither and yon without considering basic principles of taste and balance. If my Italian local is lucky enough to procure fresh white truffles in season, I have no problem with ordering a plate of spaghetti dressed with nothing but butter and a few shavings of those white truffles, and I understand that those shavings are going to put some serious additional change on the bill. But I don’t want those truffles on every damn dish on the menu. Nor do I need foie gras in a burrito, or ground Kobe beef in a hamburger.
Most of all, I don’t need caviar in a frittata. I haven’t had too much exposure to caviar, but I’ve had enough to know that if you’re shelling out big bucks for beluga or sevruga, you don’t want to gunk up those little pearls with cream or meat or vinaigrette or chopped hard-boiled egg. (Why this compulsion to serve egg with egg? Why?) Apparently, though, someone at the Parker Meridien, one of the most expensive hotels in Midtown, has decided that what their frittata special really needs is caviar. And lobster. And cream sauce, plenty of cream sauce. Thus it is that the P-M openly, freely and without shame, invites you to order this on your next visit.
The hotel’s general manager, Steven Pipes, has admitted that he doesn’t anticipate too many takers on this frittata, that he and the executive chef came up with this dish as a way to keep the menu from getting too “stale” (I still dream of the day when this sort of food fashion, “is it in or is it out?,” falls out of fashion), and that the whole thing is just a bit of a joke. I agree that it’s a joke. But it’s not funny. What it is is a waste: a waste of a good lobster, a waste of almost ¾ pound of caviar, a waste of butter and heavy cream, a waste of six eggs, all in pursuit of a stunt we should have got over playing 30 years ago.
She mentioned the book The Taste of America often enough and in enough intriguing ways that I actually went ahead and ordered a copy. (Dudette! Get an Amazon ID! Get recognition of the American sort when your recommendations are followed up! Although, I have to admit, in the case of Taste of America, I ordered off of Alibris, where the copies were much cheaper.)
Downside: not enough recipes! She mentions making incredible edibles but then mutters about “copyright” and “permission to reprint.” But…but…this is the Web! We have Fair Use! (Until such time as the Administration can repeal it, and believe me, they’re working on it.)
Since I’ve been on a baking tear of late, Jen’s writing about baking, the history of baking, and what she’s been baking are of extreme interest to me these days.
I need to become one of Bakerina’s best friends, so I can her to mail me some of her goodies…
(Btw, Jen: if you do open your own bakery, forget about calling it “Baked Goods”—it’s “Bakerina” all the way!)
Tom Dowdy says
Direct copying of recipes has always been a very ticklish subject, be that web or no. Most online food bloggers that I personally know are very careful in this area. A discussion on the IMBB forums shows this somewhat interesting tidbit:
“Our copywrite research showed that you can list the exact same list of ingrediants for a recipe, however, the directions must be different in order for you to call a recipe your own. I found that to be surprisingly generous.”
I think that even re-publishing with a cite might get you into potential trouble. Stanford’s (IIRC, your alma mater) own Fair Use website points out that people often misuse this term, and that based upon the basic four tests, publishing a copyrighted recipe is possibly over the line:
Tom Dowdy says
Crap, the link got pulled. Anyway, google for “fair use Stanford” to find the main NOLA fair use web site.
Diane says
Oh, I’m sure that posting an entire recipe isn’t Fair Use–quoting a section of the instructions might be, or as you say, the ingredients list, but I’m sure an entire entity like a recipe isn’t.
Needless to say, when she mentions the various munchies she’s making, I don’t care!
(Although Bakerina does have a few places where she gives a recipe, making sure to point out it’s in her own words.)
Bakerina says
Oh, gracious. How flattering. (Are you sure you’re not talking about my doppelganger instead?) Thank you, Diane. You know you’re getting goodies for life now…
As far as the copyright and fair use issues go, I tend to err on the side of caution. Recipes are notorious breeding grounds for plagiarism, misappropriation, outright thievery and just plain bad behavior, and have been for at least 400 years. This is why I might seem a little compulsive about identifying the source of recipes, and of making very clear that the dish is the author’s creation, but that the paraphrase of the instructions is mine. Of course, I have been known to quote text, in the context of an explication/review of the books in question. I’m not entirely comfortable with this, as I think it skirts the edge of fair use, and of course I will take down anything that an author/publisher objects to my using. But every once in a while I run across something that I think should be shared *right now*. Time will tell, I guess, if I am unprincipled or just misguided. 😉
And thank you for jogging my memory on the omelet post! I had almost forgotten about that. I don’t know if the link I had originally posted is still extant (I’m guessing not), but what got up my pipe was that the Parker-Meridian was charging $1,000.00 for that omelet, and the papers were having a field day with it. “Imagine! A $1,000.00 omelet! Would *you* pay $1,000 for an omelet?” Well, no, I wouldn’t, especially not an omelet as ill-composed as that one. Sheesh.
Thanks again, Diane. You made my weekend. 🙂